I was resigned to the idea that my walking shoes would never be cute; slipping on chunky dad sneakers, I would remind myself that these are for function, not fashion. But when Natalie Portman wore a pair of sleek black sneakers last summer, I was forced to rethink that.

Portman wore Clifton 9 GTX sneakers from Hoka, my go-to comfy sneaker brand. While Portman’s shoes still had that classic silhouette and ample cushioning (we’re not compromising on support!), the sleek, all-black design made the athletic sneakers feel shockingly cool, so much that pairing them with her cute denim cut-offs felt completely natural. Immediately, I went to grab her exact sneakers, but also found found five more affordable lookalikes, and they start at just $45.

Hoka Clifton 9 GTX Sneakers

Hoka’s Clifton 9 GTX sneakers are Portman’s exact shoes. They have moderate cushioning that’s perfect for walking and everyday runs, as well as a closed mesh design that makes them weather-resistant.

Adidas Run Falcon 5 Sneakers

If you’re looking to shop Portman’s look for less, you’ll want to grab Adidas’s Run Falcon 5 sneakers. This shoe is lightweight and has a breathable mesh design.

Skechers Go Run Consistent Sneakers

Skechers’ Go Run sneakers are another affordable alternative at just $45. They have a cushiony yet breathable insole and a chunky silhouette. For anyone obsessed with the dad sneaker trend, these are for you.

New Balance Fresh Foam Arishi V4 Running Shoes

My all-time favorite sneakers are New Balances, so I of course added the brand’s black Fresh Foam Arishi sneakers to my wishlist. What sets these apart from similar sneakers is their wider platform for a little more cushioning coverage.

Brooks Ghost 17 Running Shoes

Like Hoka, Brooks is another brand celebrities are loyal to (it’s rare to see Jennifer Garner not wearing its sneakers). On rare sale, the Ghost 17 style is available in that same all-black look, plus it has moderate support and soft cushioning.

Under Armour Charged Assert 10 Sneakers

Under Armour’s Charged Assert 10 sneakers are a shopper favorite, with more than 5,000 five-star ratings. Fans say that these feel like “walking on a cloud” and are comfortable and sturdy enough to walk five miles in.